Changes in apoptotic rate and cell viability in three fish epidermis cultures after exposure to nonylphenol and to a waste water sample containing low concentrations of nonylphenol

Three types of epidermal cultures of fish were used for toxicological investigations, a primary cell culture and a tissue culture prepared from the rainbow trout Oncorhynchus mykiss Walbaum and the cell line EPC, derived from a skin tumour of the carp Cyprinus carpio L. Two studies were carried out to compare the different culture systems. In the first cultures were incubated with nonylphenol and in the second set of experiments the cell cultures were exposed to a wastewater sample containing low concentrations of nonylphenol (NP). Both cell cultures were similarly sensitive to nonylphenol with respect to the endpoints cell viability (LC50 (24 h) 47.1 μM NP (primary cell culture) and 44.2 μM NP (EPC)) values and apoptotic rate (significantly increased apoptotic rate after exposure to 50 μM NP for 24 h, p < 0.001 (primary cell culture), p = 0.008 (EPC)). The explant culture was slightly less sensitive (increased apoptotic rate after exposure to 50 μM NP for 24 h, but not significant: p = 0.385), which could be due to the capabilities of a differentiated tissue, providing more protective repair mechanisms, compared with single cells. All cultures revealed a concentration–response relationship for the endpoint apoptotic rate after the application of nonylphenol for 24 h. After wastewater exposure, a significant decrease in the apoptotic rate was measured in the primary cell culture (dilution wastewater : medium 1:1:p = 0.018; dilution wastewater : medium 1:2:p = 0.003), whereas the cell line EPC did not reveal any effects. Our results show that the endpoint apoptotic rate is more sensitive than the parameter cell viability for detecting adverse effects of a wastewater sample.